Hot answers tagged

32

Personally I don't think it's our place to be policing supposed use of unlicensed anything unless the question is about how to get the fonts illegally or circumvent the licence in some way. I especially don't think we should be making assumptions about where people got their fonts from if they are asking an otherwise legitimate question. So questions ...


25

It seems to me that the practice may have outstripped the previous consensus. I understand that (as the original meta question posited) a question that is a bug report should be closed. Truly that is not because it is "too localized" but because it is not really a question: "I've found this bug" is a statement, not a question. The question "Why am I seeing ...


22

We vote anything and everything. We are full of contradictions. If we somehow get what the point is we leave it alone unless it's really boring and unlikely to be done in finite amount of manhour x time x etc. That is another contradiction right there. We have monthly(biweekly?) Answer the unanswered sessions where we sweep the unanswered questions so most ...


18

It's not a problem. If there would be upvoted answers, the question would not be unanswered and would go away from the "unanswered" list. No need to close, what would actually prevent further, possibly even better, answers. See on the main meta site: Would it be possible to have a “community accepted” feature? You can show your acceptance of an answer by ...


16

There's no formal policy since, of course, you can't force people to use it. With many people familiar with this habit, most packages/classes are written using <code>. And, if not, they may be edited to "conform" to this. One advantage of using an alternative <code>-markdown is that it clearly highlights when you're using a package rather than ...


14

One man's bug is another man's feature... I don't think whether the OP considers it to be a bug is that relevant. If the problem has been identified and fixed by the package author in an updated version of the package then we can consider treating the question by some special mechanism for "bug reports" otherwise it is best to assume that it's a permanent ...


14

In general, the site is intended to work as a community, so using your votes is the preferred way to push for closing. Flagging is best used for things that really need moderator attention, which is more likely to be true for older questions which might not attract other people's interest than for very recent posts that will (probably) get other close votes. ...


13

Quoting from Joel Spolsky's answer: Why is there a green Honda Civic parked out in front of my house? This is too localized because: Who cares? Is it even still there? Go check. What are the chances that this question could ever be answered in a way that would benefit anyone else? Now is it there? In order not to be ...


12

We have a couple of methods for dealing with the problem: commenting; editing. A comment could be something like Please edit your question, because, as it's formulated now, it can raise some doubts about copyright issues. On the other hand, how the questioner came in possession of the fonts is usually not relevant for solving the problem, so an edit ...


12

In the case at hand, you simply couldn't delete you answer unless the OP revoked his acceptance before. IMO, you also shouldn't delete it because it shows an alternative approach that may be useful for other users (who may face not quite the same, but a similar problem in the future). "Disciplining" yourself rather is a proper course of action if you and ...


11

Just to stir up the soup. I agree with Alan Munn on this issue but with a slightly different motivation. I'm actually quite bothered by the word swiftly. I don't mind if the question stays open or closed, either way the issue is not resolved so no need to insist on practice because next year it would really be an ancient issue but as you can see it's ...


11

The reason such question are often closed it that bugs which will be fixed soon make the question "too localiced in time" because soon they issue will be gone and there is no suitable answer beyond "update the package". Note that our "no bug questions" policy is (or should be) IMHO mostly about questions which directly cover a bug, like "why do I get this ...


10

One of the advantages of the Stackexchange model is that there are ways to discuss and in fact reverse most decisions made by the community. It seems to me that if a case can be made on an individual question that it should be reopened, the threshold for reopening is not so high that it's very difficult to do. And we have the meta site for exactly this sort ...


9

I just signed up for freelancer.ca (see edit below for more details) and basically you can look for freelancers in specific areas to do your "projects", including LaTeX. From what I can see, some of the freelancers seem to have really solid reviews and even have examples of their work. You can also post your "project" and have freelancers bid on it (but ...


9

Ironically, having just read through the answers and left a couple of comments, I headed over the main site and found Error message with hobby package which is essentially a bug report on the hobby package (which I maintain) and which has already been fixed. I would argue against closing this one because: The questioner doesn't know that it's a bug. ...


8

I'm not a lawyer, and copyright laws differ from country to country, but in the U.S., copyright does not need to be asserted: it exists the moment you produce the work. So in reality there is no such thing as "unknown copyright"; the safest assumption is that it belongs to the author or has been transferred to someone else. That said, it seems to me that ...


8

This is a little splitting the hair for my understanding. IF we force this I'm the first one who will stop using backticks :P We shouldn't have policies on such stuff because they are aids not rules. But at least we can embed some use into this pedantry if the backticked thing is a package name. We have the amazing tool of Martin Scharrer described here; ...


7

Does the package name have to be typed exactly so in the preamble or you get an error? It won't work if you use a synonym, different capitalization, or hyphenate? Why then, it really IS code after all, just a very small excerpt.


6

I think this is related to personal preferences. A community driven site typically reaches an equilibrium in determination of how to cast votes. On this site I have seen (and been a part of) closing questions which where bug-related. In this regard see the discussion in: Questions which are bug reports. This, as you suggest, might have been inadvertently ...


6

If you really feel your answer does not deserve being listed first, you have only one option: Make the OP unaccept it and accept the other one. There is no other way how to make the accept answer not to show first. As another option, you can edit your answer and add a first bold line: I believe that the answer by Alan Munn is better then mine, and I ...


6

In general, questions due to bugs should be treated no differently from any others. Thus provided the question is clear and reproducible it should be kept open, and (ideally) answered. For issues which are acknowledged bugs which have been fixed, it may be that the most straight-forward answer is 'update your TeX system' (for bugs in (La)TeX packages)/'...


5

While it would be appreciated here, the proper place on stackoverflow would probably be careers.sx, although that's too expensive for only one job. TUG has a jobboard, though.


4

Thanks for posting this - it goes a long way towards addressing the concerns I raised in chat. This site is entitled to whatever customs it deems necessary to keep up the quality of the content (or, as I suspect many here would phrase it, to "not talk about the things we cannot fix"), but the site does owe a minimal measure of clarity in why it shuts threads ...


2

Related/duplicate: What if a comment answers a question? Quite often it happens that the problem is a typo or alike and we consider it off-topic. However, in this case I would ask Ian Thompson to provide an answer, since the question carries information that can be useful to others :)


1

The linked post is an attempt to answer the question so the "not an answer" flag does not apply to it according to its description "This was posted as an answer, but it does not attempt to answer the question.". Please flag it as "low quality" if you really think it needs to converted to a comment by a moderator and not be the OP himself.


Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible