Questions tagged [close-reasons]
This tag is for instructions and guidance on closing or migrating questions, and the reasons for those closures.
48
questions
5
votes
0answers
73 views
Off topic close reason no longer available
I noticed that a reason has been added in the Close Question dialog, in the category A community-specific reason:
This reason is for non-reproducible or trivial questions, and it suggests to add an ...
2
votes
1answer
54 views
What are the new displays associated with post notices?
I noticed that the "[on hold]" reference has been deleted from questions that are closed as being unclear. Now only the word "[closed]" is written.
Are there other types of options with the new names ...
18
votes
6answers
546 views
Reasons for closing questions: too little effort
This is, in a certain way, a reiteration of Henri Menke's question/request "Please add more off-topic close reasons". At the moment of writing this, this question has one highly voted answer, which ...
0
votes
2answers
512 views
Why are the eminent contributors in such a hurry to close questions?
Here are two real facts that show that prominent contributors close questions without taking the time to read them carefully and verify that they are really a duplicate question.
First issue:
Look at ...
5
votes
1answer
48 views
Not all options listed in voting to close
I would like to understand why when the system asks me to close a question I have only three options and the other options are not visible. For example it is not viewable: the question is resolved in ...
17
votes
2answers
146 views
Migration paths suggestions
Users with "close" priviledge can mark off-topic questions to be migrated to thie Meta.TeX.SX site. I suggest to add two more migration options:
StackOverflow - for questions about MathJaX
...
6
votes
0answers
88 views
Why can't we migrate off-topic questions to other StackExchange sites?
This comment by Henri Menke has reminded me a question I wanted to ask.
Every now and then, a good question appears, but which is not concerning LaTeX and friends.
We can only close it as off-topic ...
21
votes
1answer
420 views
Please add more off-topic close reasons
Recently I have started using Stack Overflow and one thing I noticed is that their close dialog is much more feature rich than ours. Let's see a picture of their "off-topic" reasons.
Wow! ...
12
votes
0answers
59 views
Closing as OT with custom reason: why not use the custom text in the close banner?
When voting to close a question as off topic, and entering a custom close reason, should not that text be used in the "closing banner" that is displayed in the post? Given that all close-voters use ...
15
votes
3answers
437 views
Questions which are bug reports, revisited
Some time ago, I asked how we should handle bug reports: Questions which are bug reports. The top answer at the time split questions into two
Those which are asked where is seems clear that the ...
13
votes
1answer
154 views
How to flag a question concerning a software bug
How should I flag questions that are about software bugs only and, therefore, off-topic here?
I am a contributor to the JabRef reference manager and, thus, am following the JabRef tag on this site.
...
0
votes
0answers
67 views
Requests for Reopen & Undeletion Votes
There is a similar popular question at MSE.
The purpose of this thread is to help focus the attention of the community on posts that may require exceptional handling. This includes requests for ...
9
votes
1answer
183 views
Are troubleshooting questions off-topic?
Some days ago, I asked in Troubleshooting for biber for guidelines what to do/check if biber does not produce any output. The occasion to ask this question was of course that I had such a situation ...
14
votes
3answers
232 views
When flagging for close: Adding a reason
Posts on StackExchange are closed for numerous reasons, and ticking of the right box for the exact reason might not always fit the question quite right, or the reason might sometimes be very vague. ...
56
votes
1answer
694 views
Close voting is not a sport
We strive to be a friendly and rational community here, but the question below
Reducing the huge space before the first line of the KOMA letter class
was just closed as "Too broad".
This is a ...
4
votes
0answers
79 views
Off-topic closure: why so few specific reasons?
I just found this question through review -- a first post. The question is perfectly clear: the user has a problem and is asking for a solution. So it is not unclear what you're asking. I cannot say ...
12
votes
2answers
98 views
How to search for duplicates and handle them?
Finding duplicates for a question, if they exist, is not always easy. What techniques can I use to find question duplicates? How should duplicates be handled?
4
votes
1answer
200 views
Do we need a new closing reason for “do it for me” questions?
Some of the questions on this site ask community to code a picture they find over the net. Some of these questions do not have any minimum working example appended. Why do not we have a close reason ...
11
votes
1answer
378 views
How to avoid closing a question that gets more than 5k views!
This question here has been asked on May 27th, 2013 and closed the same day for the reason »This question is unlikely to help any future visitors; ...«
Today we have to realise that this question ...
14
votes
3answers
343 views
is closing this question as “off topic” a breach of site policy?
Sveinung asks, in a comment on Align equations on equal (=) symbol, whether closing a question because it
shows no no evidence of research effort is a valid reason.
the question merely shows a ...
15
votes
1answer
184 views
Wrong close reason shown
The question https://tex.stackexchange.com/questions/50373/what-dont-do-latex-text-composition shows that it is closed by me (and others) as “not constructive”. I did however vote to close it as a ...
51
votes
2answers
1k views
Reviewers; what do you eat for breakfast?
Ahem, this is going to be a rough one, so it's gonna be a long one too ala Pascal's famous quote. First, some context; we have
How to deal with robo-reviewers?
Should we have a Grace period to avoid ...
6
votes
1answer
189 views
Does this question qualify as off-topic? Does it violate any rules at all?
A couple of days ago, the following question was put on hold as off-topic:
How to get "XeLaTeX + unicode-math" output as close as possible to that of pdflatex?
I asked this question over a ...
15
votes
1answer
115 views
Incorrect tag used to zap a question by the golden badge hammer
I found this strange thing which is IMHO a bug:
The problem is that egreg zapped the question using his golden xetex badge. However, the question isn't tagged xetex, it had the tag but lost it ...
19
votes
1answer
248 views
Why are 'mistaken' questions marked off-topic?
Fairly often I see questions which are in fact about Tex & friends but are closed & marked off-topic. One reason I see listed in the comments is:
This question is off-topic because it ...
3
votes
1answer
203 views
Questions put on hold as opinion based
I wanted to know where LaTeX is lacking with the idea that I could develop patches for it. I believe, it is not an opinion based question. Definitely, whatever developed, will have room for ...
10
votes
2answers
209 views
Questions closed as “unclear what you're asking”
I've seen quite a few questions proposed to be closed as "unclear what you're asking":
https://tex.stackexchange.com/review/close/34255
https://tex.stackexchange.com/review/close/34260
https://tex....
12
votes
2answers
199 views
Question about “is it possible without using specific packages”
This question has been closed as a duplicate. The OP was asking "whether it is possible to do something without the use of specific packages" and the duplicate reference only have answer about loading ...
1
vote
0answers
105 views
Why is this question closed?
This question has more than 2k views in just over 15 months. I too am experiencing the File not Found message and this question describes my problem. I notice that the person who asked this question ...
16
votes
1answer
209 views
How to deal with a question that turned out to be an installation problem?
Yesterday I had a small discussion in the comments of https://tex.stackexchange.com/q/134974/18674. It turned out that the problem was caused by an old version of a package that had changed some of ...
14
votes
1answer
325 views
Why are “typography” and “best-practices” possible tags but are not mentioned in the list of “What topics can I ask about here”?
The question came up, when this post How should I typeset the physical dimensions of quantities? got closed for being off-topic. We discussed it in chat, and it seem to be a bit tricky. That's why I ...
10
votes
2answers
190 views
Off-topic closure: predefined reasons
The new approach to closing questions means that things are changing in the way we handle 'off-topic' questions. I've already asked about the generic text and for some predefined off-topic close ...
6
votes
0answers
76 views
Off-topic closure: migration paths
In a related post I've asked (again) about custom 'off-topic' closure texts. As I note there, the second thing we need to address if closing as off-topic is a reasonable set of places on the ...
24
votes
1answer
233 views
New close reasons: use of new 'unclear what you're asking' reason
We will soon see the arrival of the new close reasons (a change being implemented across the StackExchange network). This will raise a few question: here I want to focus specifically the 'unclear what ...
17
votes
3answers
264 views
New close reasons: selecting predefined 'off-topic' options
We will soon see the arrival of the new close reasons (a change being implemented across the StackExchange network). This will raise a few question: here I want to focus specifically the 'off-topic' ...
23
votes
0answers
206 views
What do I do if I have the exact same question as a question that is closed as 'too localized'?
I've been struggling with unnecessary blank pages at the beginning of appendices. There are a few answers that speak to my problem, none of which have worked. I was pleased to find another person ...
12
votes
2answers
331 views
Where usage meets TeX
We recently closed a maths usage question, Can I use both of setbuilder notations in one article?, which asked for whether it is acceptable to use two different comprehension notations in one article, ...
24
votes
7answers
346 views
Why are questions on package bugs/issues too localized?
On a couple of occasions I have come across unwanted or surprising behavior with some widely used LaTeX packages that I have posted questions about on TeX.sX. One was about biblatex (Entry options in ...
15
votes
3answers
305 views
How to ask a specific question without in the risk of “too localized”?
One may met problems in document writing, some of them are specific that rarely to met by others. So questions asked for seeking resolutions for these problems are often marked "too localized". But if ...
19
votes
3answers
381 views
About “trivial” questions
I have a question regarding "trivial" questions which sometimes appear on this site. By "trivial", I mean they don't require more insight than to "look in the manual". These usually aren't good ...
16
votes
1answer
179 views
Keeping a log of potentially duplicate, TL, NARQ, questions
We often comment on questions, asking the original poster to try and improve their question- the standard comments include:
Can you provide a minimal working example?
Can you show what you have tried ...
20
votes
4answers
808 views
Speaking of LaTeX editors
Currently there are 505 questions tagged lyx, 184 tagged emacs, 92 tagged texniccenter, 89 tagged vim, 47 tagged texstudio, 54 tagged winedt. Producing La/TeX from the command line is theoretically ...
14
votes
1answer
325 views
Why is this Question considered off-topic?
This Question was mistakenly migrated to WordPress Answers and closed here. Questions in WPSE relating to WordPress.com-hosted blogs are clearly off-topic there, per FAQ. So the Question was closed ...
18
votes
4answers
459 views
Same disease, different symptoms
We often have the case where two questions are asked by users facing completely different phenomenon, but where if you have the right understanding, you can see that the same thing is going on in each ...
9
votes
1answer
196 views
Delete or close my question (MikTeX can’t find xstring)
I asked MikTeX can’t find xstring, because I wasn’t sure what the problem is and although I googled miktex xstring a didn’t found anything especially not the bug report that Ulrike linked in her ...
4
votes
3answers
220 views
Reason for closure of a question
I am wondering what was the reason to close my question Underfull \hbox and Underfull \vbox as being too localized. The question asks what for ways to fix the warning "Underfull \hbox and Underfull \...
16
votes
1answer
174 views
Possible duplicate - Exact Duplicate
This might be a duplicate but:
When a question is closed for being a possible duplicate it adds an automatic header
But in the closing explanation, we also have:
Is there any difference between ...
5
votes
1answer
158 views
Why was this question closed?
Why was the question Strange persisting error, even after removing the code. closed without comment? Did the OP request it?
It is not a great question, but I'd have rather rewritten it to be more ...
