To me it seems that some people do not take the review feature serious enough. I see several questions by new members that need serious improvements. How can this functionality be improved?

  • 2
    have the questions you noticed actually been listed under one of the review categories? fairly often i see questions that could be improved, but they're neither listed for review, nor shown as having been edited. (i don't usually check the review history separately from edit history.) i think that only certain items are triggered automatically for review (in fact, i don't really know how the review listing is generated), so it may be possible that reviewing was never suggested, even if it would have been appropriate. – barbara beeton Jan 23 '14 at 16:04
  • @barbarabeeton: You are right. Neither I know exactly how the list is generated, but I think all first questions from new members (if they do not have 100 reputation at another page) are marked for review. – strpeter Jan 23 '14 at 16:33
  • 4
    To echo what @percusse has said in his answer, We as TeX.SX are known for and proud of our friendliness. Any 'serious' improvements that come to mind are often just the peculiarities/compulsions of one writing style reviewing another. I personally take the reviewing process pretty seriously—it is a privilege—but never do I risk offense in correcting someone unless the verbiage or formatting impedes the understanding of the question. – Sean Allred Jan 23 '14 at 23:43

Well indeed I don't take it seriously because it's not a serious feature. Some users already took away its functionality long ago and as barbara mentioned I've not seen a single new user question in the reviews since a year and some months. Probably the review system distributes the reviews to some users and locks for others to (wildly guessing here) reduce the review clashes.

I recommend editing the questions directly instead of that review system as much as you see them on the site. Nothing came good out of that system as far as I know other than light speed question closing.

Also no improvement is serious here. Because serious tone always causes trouble.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .