Look at Why are empty and non empty TikZ matrix cells not equally placed?. When I wrote it I didn't know the answer so its title was too general. Now, and because I think it's not so easy to find questions/answers in TeX.SX even I know I've read them, I think this general title is not so informative and I'm considering to change it with something like why are empty and not empty cell in TikZ matrices missplaced?or whatever you like.

Now my question is not only related whit this particular title but more general. Is it good to change question titles to make them more accurate with their answers?

  • 19
    IMHO yes. A title that better describes the issue will easier be found by others with similar problems which means that the question can be of more help to others. – clemens Oct 24 '13 at 21:18
  • Also under the condition the edit does not break the front line scroll Queue too often. Somewhat Related to Q Titles Limiting the Length of Subject Titles – texenthusiast Oct 25 '13 at 3:10
  • 9
    One thing to beware of is that you should make sure the question title is still informative to someone who does not know the answer. – Charles Staats Oct 25 '13 at 17:38

Check these questions (and their answers):

The answer is: Not really, but there is more to it. Now, improving your title is great, you should do that, but not make it too based on the answers. Improve the title by itself and for itself, because whoever gets to your same problem will not know about the solution and will use what they know to search for the answer on Google. So by titling your question using the answers you're not helping who needs a solution. You should edit taking that into account.

If the title is too general it's not going to help either, so I agree that it would need editing as well, but make it independent.

On a related note, avoid tagging your question after it has been answered according to the answers. The tags are meant to categorize your question, not the answers.

In conclusion: Tag and title your question independently from its answers. If the title needs improvement, then feel free to edit and improve, that's what the edit button is for, but don't base it on the answers.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .