This is perhaps more of a personal question regarding moderation, but others might also have come across it. Hence its presence here.

The question Switch to LyX Code Keyboard Shortcut had a simple answer, actually answered by the OP. It's simplicity led to it being flagged automatically as having a "low answer quality score" and subsequently showed up in the 10K-tools review. Since I followed the original commentary of the question and its subsequent answer, I flagged it as being an "invalid flag"; perhaps considering it my 2-cents worth of contributing:

enter image description here

However, as seen above, this was "disputed" by a moderator. What should one do in such cases? For example, I thought this was a valid use of an "invalid flag" flag.

1 Answer 1


You've acted entirely correctly: the whole point of the 10k tools is to spread the load of keeping on top of issues beyond a small group of mods to everyone who has 'invested' heavily in the site. On the particular question you point to, I'm not quite sure what the 'disputed' is supposed to mean. Like you, I felt the answer was fine, with the shortness 'confusing' the automated tools. I dismissed the flag: presumably the flag itself is therefore disputed, rather than your suggesting 'invalid'.

  • From a site user's perspective, it seems like there are two visible flags: helpful, or disputed (not counting ignored flags that float away into the abyss). And those two could be considered polar opposites: the former being a pat on the back; the latter being a kick in the backside. :) Note that helpful flags are badge-appropriate, and one might be inclined to only flag where it will be helpful...
    – Werner Mod
    Jun 18, 2012 at 7:53
  • Could any “disagree” flag be automatically “disputed” (by the user who raised the original flag)? Doesn't really make sense for flags raised by system itself, but maybe SE treats these flags the same way as user-raised flags for simplicity.
    – Caramdir
    Jun 18, 2012 at 17:01
  • As is answered in “It has invalid flags” flag - when resolving, mark as opposite to other flags, one could consider "helpful" flags as carrying a weight of +1, "disputed" a weight of 0 and "rejected" a weight of -1 (I guess in-line with the original flag weight system). Admittedly, "disputed" has a more negative connotation than being considered "neutral."
    – Werner Mod
    Mar 10, 2014 at 5:46

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .