19

Fairly often I see questions which are in fact about Tex & friends but are closed & marked off-topic. One reason I see listed in the comments is:

This question is off-topic because it simply stems from a misinterpretation of the [insert-pkg-name-here] documentation.

Isn't the appropriate action to answer the question with an explanation of how the user is mistaken? Explain what they misinterpreted rather than just designating their mistake as off-topic?

If one user has misinterpreted the documentation, other users have or will make the same mistake. An answer explaining the mistake is more useful than an 'off-topic' tag.

2
  • Can you point to any specific question? That may help...
    – Werner Mod
    Commented Jun 5, 2014 at 5:46
  • I'd prefer not to point fingers. It does seem that closing questions as off-topic is more common on Tex.SE vs other SE sites. Maybe my question is a bit rhetorical as written; I'm not sure how to improve it ATM though.
    – patricktokeeffe
    Commented Jun 5, 2014 at 6:06

1 Answer 1

Reset to default
27

There are a few things to say here. First off, the StackExchange 'back end' works in the same way for all sites, which means that 'we' (TeX-SX) have to use the structures as decided on by the 'Powers'. Occasionally that means we have some oddities. That leads to the second point: 'off topic' is (currently) intended not only to cover questions which are out-and-out not about TeX, etc., but also for things that are not answered 'by convention' (I'll return to this below). The latter has tended to include stuff like typos, mistakes reading the docs and so on. The logic there is that the StackExchange 'concept' is that it's not a forum in the sense that the same question shouldn't be answered over-and-over and answers shouldn't be so focussed on the OP that they will never be of use to anyone else. Things like typos, needing to update a TeX system or misunderstandings tend to fall into this category: the specific question is not likely to get asked again, and any answer would probably not help another user.

All that said, probably the biggest reason here is that we don't have what we used to have: a close reason that is focussed specifically on a question being too narrow. The 'Powers' got rid of 'Too Localized' as they felt that it was being misused (across the network): the StackExchange intention for this was it applied to only things that could never be seen by anyone other than the OP, rather than being used for the type of case I've outlined (typos for example can come up on a lot of sites, and most don't answer them). The Powers have been very definite that such closings are because the question is 'off topic' (perhaps 'out of scope').

I think it's fair to say that many of us feel that closing these 'localized' questions is the right approach ('read the manual' is not really adding value) but would prefer a better reason than 'off topic'. However, at present we don't have one.

Note that in some cases the best approach with 'good' basic questions is to sort out a canonical answer and then dupe to it. Probably the most obvious example is Question mark or bold citation key instead of citation number, which is a good question with a good answer to a very common issue.

3
  • 2
    Great answer, Josef!
    – Werner Mod
    Commented Jun 5, 2014 at 17:31
  • 3
    I think the same goes for what we sometimes consider as do-it-for-me questions. They are typically closed as "Not clear what is being asked", although it is obviously apparent what the user wants or what is asked. It's just that we are funnelled into certain responses by the system we use.
    – Werner Mod
    Commented Jun 6, 2014 at 14:06
  • 1
    Needed to say, typos, do-it-for-me and outdated installations in our site are not the only ones that miss Too Localized. Certainly some very specific questions on Academia.SE have the same problem. It's ridiculous that question directly on-topic are marked as off-topic because they are too localized. "Topic" is simply a wrong word here, because topic is fine; it's the nature of the question that makes it unsuitable.
    – yo'
    Commented Jun 10, 2014 at 11:40

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .